Homelessness: Why Tent Cities Aren’t the Solution

Slum resized 600

In every industry, social group and sub-culture, there are dogmas and popular trends that have certain cache and are given more importance than they merit. Some people call this political correctness, others have named it “group think” or a herd mentality. Regardless, it exists, it’s real and it carries weight with all of us.

We feel social pressure when we don’t go along with the group, and fear being ostracized if we suggest that this “group think” mentality exists.

This is true in the world of professional social services; there are many commonly held dogmas that are rarely challenged and have become part of politcally correct speech.

Included in these topics are opinions on “Tent Cities”; homeless camps authorized by local municipalities to alleviate homelessness. The vast majority of opinions on tent cities seem to fall into a similar category. What you think about tent cities has become a litmus test for homeless advocacy, and anyone who speak out against them will be swimming against the current.

In spite of the fact that it is unpopular to do so, I have felt compelled for years to argue against tent cities in any way I can, because the facts and realities of these communities are completely at odds with the charitable descriptions you hear about them.

Here’s why I think Tent Cities aren’t a good solution for local communities:

1. They don’t “Scale Up”. One way to test the premise of whether a social service is useful, not enabling, and not dangerous, is to ask the question, “What if we did this on a massive scale?” Having spent seven years working in the third world, amongst some of the poorest people on earth, many millions of which were living in shanty towns (third world tent cities), I can assure you that this idea doesn’t scale.  

2.  They’re not Humane. Tent cities set the bar of human dignity too low. Living on the street involves exposure to the elements, danger, constant fear and near constant need for mobility. It doesn’t allow for the important nurturing, stability, safety and other key needs that humans need. Tent cities also fall woefully short of meeting these criteria.  

3.  Negative Social Impacts.  Congregating people who are homeless together has social impacts. This is true of homeless shelters and other types of social services, but many of those impacts can be mitigated by organizations entering into enforcable social contracts with the neighborhood in which they exist. Tent cities try to maintain social contracts but the defused nature of responsibility within them affords them little leverage to enforce civil and lawful behavior. Allowing each person to be a law unto themselves results in a proliferation of drug use. Tent city advocates point to certain examples of lawful tent cities, but they are the exception, not the rule, and many of those promoted don’t pass muster under further inspection.  

4.  Relief Value for Political Solutions. Many cities understand that homelessness, particularly family homelessness, is a growing problem. This problem can only be solved when municipalities work together with social service providers to create programs, facilities and funding to solve the issues that lead to homelessness. Tent cities stunt the growth of these critical services because they alleviate political pressure to create meaningful solutions.

There are other temporary solutions, including increased funding of “freezing night” programs that get people into motels/hotels and rental housing during inclemate weather. This approach gets people off the street without having the negative social impacts and dangers of tent cities. Sometimes the solution to the problem makes the problem worse. This is the case with tent cities.

What do you think? Are tent cities the wave of the future? Is there a way to do a tent city that provides dignity, safety, and doesn’t stunt the growth of permanent housing, shelters and important services?

David Curry

Read all of David Curry’s blogs at http://blog.rescue-mission.org or visit the Rescue Mission at http://www.rescue-mission.org.

My All-Time Fav Books

describe the imageMy friend John Pearson, managment guru and great guy, has asked his friends to send him a picture of your “ultimate bookshelf.”  Here’s the link to John’s page, but I thought I’d include the pic of my ultimate books and my personal note to John.  Hope you find it interesting.
John, of course I’m not satisfied with just being able to pick a few books since almost any short list feels totally incomplete. However, I picked a few that were meaningful and filled a “type” of book that has been instrumental in my personal and professional growth. 
The Road Less Traveled has been a pivotal book in my life, I’ve read it over 20 times, and was the book that helped me begin to understand some of the pain and dysfunction in the world and how to deal with it. 
Theodore Rex is a wonderful and well written biography but also represents all the free life lessons I’ve gleaned from reading biographies of consequential men and women. 
Now Discover Your Strengths was a book the helped me find the language to explain why and how my gifts/talents/perspective are unique…in a good way. There aren’t many more important issues than figuring out how you’re wired and the context where you are best suited. 
Good to Great is another classic that represents a type of book that has helped me steer a more strategic and healthy path for those I lead. 
The Tipping Point was a book that really spoke to me, as much for the interesting use of story to bring facts to life as for it’s main point – explaining how trends and social epidemics happen.  

David Curry

How Much Info Is Too Much Info?

In this new world, with instant broadcasting of our actions, emotions, and thoughts, it is helpful to stop and consider when the sharing of information is not helpful. I once heard someone say,"Don't share a problem with those who cannot be part of … [Continue reading]

Lessons I’ve Learned From Benchmarking

The idea of benchmarking, looking at other companies and industries to see where you relate according to their level of excellence, has been around a long time but that doesn't mean it's grown stale. In fact, it may be more important than ever. With … [Continue reading]

Following Your Gut, Not Just Data

The greatest innovators, revolutionaries, and leaders are those that have an instinct that goes against the grain of conventional wisdom, against the numbers and the prognosticators. It was just a few years ago that Steve Jobs rolled out his idea for … [Continue reading]

Why Order & Structure are Foundational to Success

When life gets crazy, with ideas, problems and challenges popping up all over the place, I like to slow down and make a "to do list." No matter how frenetic life gets, making a list always settles me down and helps me to begin to unwind all the … [Continue reading]

Keeping Your Life, Work, & Relationships Fresh

  It's not uncommon for people to feel like they're going through the motions, stuck in a rut of sameness in their relationships, job, and overall life. How can you make sure this doesn't happen to you? Be a learner! Discovery brings reserves of … [Continue reading]

A Beautiful and More Fulfilling Life

Do you know what your actions, life, family, business or organization is communicating? Every thing you do says something about what you value and believe.   Recently I've been so impressed by the actions and message of Pope Francis. Coming into … [Continue reading]

Why and How to Use Non-Profit Consultants

Could you imagine doing surgery on yourself? Even if you theoretically knew what ailment was bothering you, you'd be wise to get an outside opinion, perhaps a specialist in the field or just another set of eyes to look at the problem. … [Continue reading]

Non-profit Leaders: Experimenting Your Way to Greatness

Jeff Bezos, CEO at Amazon, has famously said, "It's not an experiment if you know how it's going to turn out."   Experimenting as a leader and manager - trying out projects, products, programs, systems, and theories - is a necessary tool to … [Continue reading]